Is the old tradition of asking the bride’s father still valued in modern day society?

You have made up your mind, you want to propose, congratulations, but now the panic sets in, ‘oh no, do I have to ask her father’s permission?’

For any traditional down on one knee kind of guy this is a no-brainer, but for other less conventional men this is
not even a question that occurs to them.
However, this isn’t a decision that affects only you.

You are going to ask a girl to become your wife, to start a new life together, but you will also become part of her family too and asking her father’s permission might be very important to her.

You should know if you don’t already what your soon to be fiancée thinks of the whole concept of her father giving you permission to ask her to marry you. Here are some helpful pointers to help navigate the whole process.

[polldaddy poll=6034634]

How important will it be to her, but also her father?

What kind of home background is she from? Are her parents still together, does she even still talk to her father?
Simply put, if she laughs off the idea then don’t give it a seconds more thought, but if she says that her dad specifically said he would kill the man who presumed to marry his little girl without permission then it is best to ask the future father-in-law first.
Even so, in today’s liberally minded society approaching another man for permission to essentially possess his daughter is kind of weird. But, some traditions, especially marital are ancient and should be respected.

Face to face or over the phone?

Where at all possible try and do this conversation in person face to face, if this is not the case due to distance a phone call is still better than nothing. So, make sure that you get a private meeting or at least some private time with your girlfriend’s dad when you can. Often meeting at a neutral spot will help calm your nerves, a loud sports bar after several large scotches is also not going to go down too well.

It would be best to make sure he knows this is a man to man talk that should not be shared and very simply make clear your feelings for his daughter.

Promise to love and protect his little girl for all time and hope that he isn’t an ass about the whole thing, or in a perfect world bursts out laughing in your face and says yes. Always remember that a girl’s relationship with her father is very important be that for good or for bad. For those women lucky enough to have a healthy relationship with their dad his approval is all-important and more to the point your respect for that is essential too.

How long do you wait when you have asked his permission?

Now that you have asked the second most important person don’t wait too long till you ask the big question. Keep the momentum going and also be sure to give the dad a heads up as to when it may happen. Also try and ask the father to keep this under his hat, when more people know the more chance of it slipping out! The first call you make will be to her parents so make sure they don’t have major plans that day as they will want to celebrate and congratulate you both.




Cory and Allison’s Rockefeller ice skating proposal.

With hundreds of spectators watching Cory skated to the centre of the ice to ask Allison to marry him! Having captured the whole build up we were there to photograph this amazing moment for Cory and Allison. The couple had flown in from Chicago for the weekend and the crowd all cheered as Allison said […]

Comments: 0 Read More »

Michael and Adrienne’s Hoboken proposal.

On a beautiful, cold and sunny Saturday morning Michael and Adrienne went for a stroll along the water front in Hoboken. With our cameras ready we were able to capture the whole build up and the proposal! With a portrait session afterwards, their whole engagement was captured on camera forever. Congratulation to Michael and Adrienne […]

Comments: 2 Read More »

Steve and Jessica’s cupcake proposal

Steve and Jessica’s cupcake Proposal in New York City   Steve contacted Pap The Question wanting to capture his proposal to Jessica. Magnolia bakery was the back drop and with some sneaky pictures of them getting cupcakes, we then captured the moment he dropped to one knee to ask Jessica to marry him. The next […]

Comments: 0 Read More »

Is the tradition of women proposing on the 29th of Feb sexist?

This February 29th all the single ladies have the chance to put a ring on him if they want. That is because every leap year in keeping with the feeling of nature being turned upside down, women are able to propose to their man. Known as ‘Ladies Privilege’, the tradition is shrouded in myth but […]

Comments: 1 Read More »

Top tips when planning your engagement proposal

This could be the most important day of your life. It could set the scene for many happy years ahead, so why leave things to chance. Plan your engagement proposal as much as you can! We’ve put together a few of our top tips when planning to pop the question, but if you’d prefer to […]

Comments: 1 Read More »

Ernie and Sarah’s Chicago engagement which was featured on Windy City Live

Ernie and Sarah’s amazing Chicago riverfront engagement featured on Windy City Live! Ernie contacted us from one of our jewelers in the Chicago area Burdeen’s Jewelery. This spot was really special to Ernie and Sarah as they always come here after along day and walk the river front so it was the perfect location for him […]

Comments: 2 Read More »

Top 5 Caribbean Honeymoon Destinations.

Susan Stuart from Valerie Wilson Travel gives her top 5 Caribbean Honeymoon Destinations. Now that you are engaged why don’t you take your dream honeymoon to the tropical shores of a beautiful Caribbean Island? What could be more wonderful with your first step off the plane than to feel the warm breeze on your face, […]

Comments: 0 Read More »

Say hello to Susan Stuart our own personal travel agent

We are extremely lucky to have Susan Stuart from Valerie Wilson Travel as our own personal travel agent. She can take care of all your travel needs and make the perfect honeymoon a breeze for you and your new wife… over to you Susan! Hi, my name is Susan Stuart. I am a travel agent […]

Comments: 1 Read More »

Ladies! Get proposing on the 29th of February – it’s a tradition you know…

OK, so we know it’s Valentine’s Day in February and that there will be thousands of guys out there ready to propose on the most romantic day of the year, but as 2012 is a leap year, the old tradition of ‘St Bridget’s complaint’ comes into play for you ladies. The leap year engagement tradition […]

Comments: 0 Read More »